Strategic Tenant Mix Optimization for NOI Growth

With margin pressure mounting and retail trends shifting fast, landlords can no longer afford to leave tenant mix to chance. NOI growth today hinges less on rent bumps and more on strategic reconfiguration.

At CRE 360, we work with owners who understand that their real estate is a dynamic ecosystem. When the right tenants are placed strategically, the result is more than occupancy—it’s activation. Here’s how to optimize your mix to unlock NOI growth.

What Is NOI and Why Tenant Mix Matters

Net Operating Income (NOI) is the cornerstone metric for property value and investor performance. It reflects the cash flow generated by your property after operating expenses are deducted, excluding financing and capital expenditures.

What many landlords overlook is how profoundly tenant mix impacts NOI:

• Revenue: Tenant type influences base rents, percentage rents, and co-tenancy synergies that can lift adjacent store sales.
• Expenses: Some tenants bring higher maintenance demands, while others contribute to lower turnover, reduced vacancy downtime, and shared marketing efforts.

A well-matched tenant mix creates compounding value. For example, a specialty grocer or fitness concept can lift foot traffic across the center, increasing visibility and sales for surrounding tenants. Conversely, a poorly performing or misaligned anchor can depress traffic and erode value across multiple leases.

Further Reading: ICSC — Understanding Retail Real Estate Economics

Step 1: Audit Your Current Tenant Mix

The first step in tenant mix optimization isn’t about who to bring in—it’s about understanding what’s already there. Most underperforming centers don’t suffer from lack of space; they suffer from mismatched tenants and misaligned expectations.

Here’s what to assess:

• Performance Gaps: Identify which tenants are truly driving value by evaluating sales productivity, rent as a percentage of sales, and contribution to foot traffic.
• Foot Traffic Dynamics: Evaluate whether your anchor tenants are generating activity that benefits adjacent in-line tenants—or simply functioning as standalone destinations.
• Trade Area Fit: Compare your current mix with the needs and preferences of the surrounding community. Does the property serve daily needs, experiential visits, or both? What are your customers coming for—and what’s missing?

Pro Tip: Look beyond demographics. Understanding shopper behavior and lifestyle preferences is key to aligning your mix with market demand.

Step 2: Conduct a Void and Gap Analysis

A fully leased shopping center can still be underperforming if it’s not meeting the needs of its market. That’s where void analysis and retail gap assessments come in—they help uncover unrealized opportunities by identifying what should be there but isn’t.

Key steps in the process:

• Identify Missing Categories: Compare your current tenant lineup to regional benchmarks and consumer demand to identify underrepresented uses.
• Evaluate Daily Needs vs. Destination Drivers: Is your center convenient for daily errands, or does it offer experiences that bring people in and keep them longer? The best-performing properties often do both.
• Look for Synergies, Not Just Categories: It’s not just about filling in blanks—it’s about creating a tenant ecosystem where uses support and strengthen one another.

Centers that add high-utility uses like medical services, boutique fitness, or pet care often experience both longer dwell times and more frequent visits, which benefit adjacent tenants and lift overall performance. According to Retail TouchPoints, shopping centers that incorporate these types of experience-driven or service-based tenants see an average increase in dwell time of 20–40% compared to centers focused solely on traditional retail.

Insight: Gap analysis is not just for leasing—it informs marketing, placemaking, and long-term repositioning. It’s your foundation for strategic growth.

Step 3: Curate Complementary Tenants, Not Just Categories

Optimizing your tenant mix isn’t a box-checking exercise—it’s a strategic design process. The most effective shopping centers build synergy between tenants, turning isolated leases into a unified customer experience.

What that looks like in practice:

• A boutique fitness studio draws morning traffic that spills into a juice bar or café next door.
• A specialty grocer anchors daily routines and consistently drives visibility for neighboring personal care tenants.
• A pediatric clinic or urgent care introduces essential, high-frequency visits that support weekday foot traffic.

Beyond simply covering categories, the goal is to orchestrate co-tenancy based on how people actually move through the property.

Top-performing mixes today blend:

• Necessity Retail: Grocers, medical, pet care, and QSR concepts that meet everyday needs
• Experience-Based Uses: Fitness, wellness, dining, and entertainment that encourage dwell time and repeat visits
• Digital-Resilient Retailers: Brands that offer services or tactile products not easily replaced online

Insight: Don’t just follow market trends—anchor your tenant strategy in the behavior and expectations of your ideal shopper.

Step 4: Use Leasing Strategy to Drive NOI Growth

Even with the right tenant categories and mix, NOI won’t improve without the leasing strategy to match. Leasing isn’t just transactional—it’s a tool to shape long-term value.

Here’s how smart leasing lifts NOI:

• Rent Escalations: Structured increases over time protect cash flow from inflation and contribute to valuation growth.
• Flexible Terms for Emerging Brands: Shorter initial terms or pop-up agreements can help test new concepts while limiting long-term risk.
• Co-Op Marketing Contributions: Shared promotional budgets allow tenants to benefit from collective foot traffic without shifting all the cost to ownership.
• CAM Recovery Optimization: Common Area Maintenance (CAM) charges should be structured to reflect how tenants actually use shared spaces—ensuring fair and consistent cost recovery across diverse tenant types.

Just as important as the lease language is the sequencing of deals. Strategic timing of renewals and new leases can smooth out expirations, maintain leverage, and prevent long periods of underperformance.

Tip: Leasing shouldn’t just fill space—it should align with your long-term asset plan and financial model.

Before and After: Hypothetical Center

Let’s consider a 120,000-square-foot suburban shopping center with a familiar profile:

• A legacy big-box anchor with declining draw
• National apparel tenants struggling with foot traffic
• 20% inline vacancy
• NOI stalled at $1.2M annually

Now, let’s reimagine it with a strategic repositioning plan focused on tenant mix:

Hypothetical Optimization Scenario:

• Anchor Repositioned with a potential high-frequency tenant pairing, such as a regional grocer and a healthcare use (e.g., urgent care), to stabilize traffic patterns.
• Inline Bays Consolidated to support a boutique fitness or wellness concept—improving daytime activation and cross-traffic potential.
• Low-Performing Spaces Repurposed as a compact food hall, reducing tenant improvement (TI) costs through shared infrastructure and simplified buildout.
• Lease Terms Adjusted to include percentage rent components where appropriate, aligning landlord upside with tenant performance.

Illustrative Outcome:
In a center of this size, a repositioning plan focused on high-frequency anchors, consolidated uses, and category diversification could drive a 25–35% NOI increase within the first 18–24 months, with further upside as newer leases stabilize and revenue-sharing models take effect. The pace of impact depends on execution speed, market demand, and timing of lease commencements—but even a moderate shift in tenant mix can create meaningful long-term value.

Conclusion: Tenant Mix Is Your NOI Strategy

In today’s retail landscape, success isn’t defined by occupancy alone—it’s defined by activation. A thoughtfully curated tenant mix has the power to reshape how consumers interact with your property, how long they stay, how often they return, and how much value each square foot generates.

Tenant mix optimization is no longer optional for property owners looking to compete with new developments, evolving consumer behavior, and a shifting leasing environment. It’s one of the most direct, controllable strategies to elevate NOI and long-term asset performance.

The good news? You don’t have to overhaul everything. The path forward starts with a clear view of what’s working, what’s missing, and how each leasing decision ladders into long-term results.

Ready to Optimize Your Center’s Performance?

Let CRE 360 help you unlock NOI through strategic tenant mix planning and execution.

Request an Expert ReviewWe’ll evaluate your current mix, identify untapped opportunities, and provide next-step guidance tailored to your center, your market, and your goals.

‍