Turning Anchor Strategy into Portfolio Performance: A Data-Driven Approach for Landlords

Starting with Strategic Validation

We recently partnered with a developer evaluating a grocery tenant opportunity. While the brand had strong market presence and the initial economics appeared favorable, our systematic analysis revealed important considerations: potential market saturation, demographic alignment questions, and co-tenancy dynamics that warranted deeper evaluation.

This collaborative approach—combining market intelligence with transaction expertise—helped our client make an informed decision based on comprehensive data rather than surface-level appeal.

It's an example of how anchor strategy has evolved. Success today requires looking beyond occupancy to understand the ecosystem value an anchor creates across your entire property.

Here's how to fix that.

Evolving Beyond Traditional Anchor Economics

The traditional approach to anchor tenants served the industry well for decades:

• Recognized brand provides credibility
• Long-term lease ensures stability
• Below-market rent justified by traffic generation

These fundamentals still matter. However, today's market dynamics require a more sophisticated approach.

With retail formats evolving rapidly and consumer behavior shifting, anchor decisions carry greater strategic weight. A single anchor choice influences your property's performance trajectory for the next decade. Yet many properties still evaluate anchors primarily on occupancy and rent rather than total value creation.

The opportunity: When selected and structured strategically, an anchor becomes more than a tenant—it becomes a catalyst that can drive:

• Accelerated leasing velocity for complementary spaces
• Stronger achieved rents through co-tenancy synergies
• Enhanced tenant retention in anchor-adjacent locations

This requires a systematic, data-driven approach to anchor evaluation and deal structuring.

A Practical Framework for Anchor Evaluation

Through our work with landlords and developers across diverse markets, we've developed a systematic approach to anchor assessment. This framework helps properties evaluate potential anchors beyond traditional metrics:

Component 1: Trade Area and Customer Alignment

Key Question: How well does the anchor's core customer match your property's natural trade area?

Our analysis typically examines:

• Demographic alignment: The overlap between the anchor's target customer and your trade area demographics
• Visit patterns: Whether the anchor drives daily, weekly, or monthly trips—and what that means for your tenant mix
• Spending capacity: Category-specific purchasing power in your market

Practical application: Strong alignment between your trade area characteristics and the anchor's customer base creates natural cross-shopping opportunities that benefit your entire tenant roster.

Component 2: Traffic Timing and Flow Analysis

Key Question: When does the anchor generate traffic, and how does that align with your existing tenants' peak periods?

We help clients map:

• Peak traffic distribution throughout the day
• Weekday versus weekend patterns
• Seasonal variations in customer flow

Practical application: Understanding temporal patterns helps ensure your tenant mix can capitalize on anchor-generated traffic. A fitness concept with early morning peaks requires different complementary tenants than a grocer with evening rush traffic.

Component 3: Co-Tenancy Synergies

Key Question: Which tenant categories benefit most from proximity to this anchor?

Through market observation and performance data, we've identified typical synergy patterns:

• Grocery anchors typically strengthen: QSR, services, convenience retail
• Off-price anchors typically strengthen: Beauty, value apparel, home goods
• Medical anchors typically strengthen: Wellness, childcare, healthy dining

Practical application: Mapping these relationships helps you identify which prospective tenants will see the most value in your property, supporting stronger lease terms.

Component 4: Operational Flexibility and Evolution

Key Question: Can this anchor adapt as retail continues evolving?

Important considerations include:

• Financial stability for long-term partnership
• Willingness to evolve formats and integrate new retail models
• Commitment to omnichannel strategies that drive both digital and physical engagement

Practical application: Partners who demonstrate flexibility and innovation capability become long-term assets rather than legacy challenges.

Creating Win-Win Anchor Agreements

The most successful anchor relationships balance the needs of both parties while creating value for the entire property. Here's how we help clients structure agreements that work for everyone:

Comprehensive Value Creation

Rather than focusing solely on base rent, consider the complete value exchange:

Financial Structure:

• Base rent balanced with percentage rent opportunities
• CAM contributions that maintain fairness across all tenants
• Performance-based adjustments tied to property success metrics

Partnership Elements:

• Marketing collaboration that amplifies both brands
• Data sharing for mutual benefit and strategic planning
• Event coordination that drives center-wide traffic

Long-term Flexibility:

• Adaptation clauses for evolving retail formats
• Portfolio considerations for multi-property owners
• Periodic review mechanisms to ensure continued alignment

Strategic Data Partnerships

One often-overlooked opportunity in anchor negotiations is establishing data exchange agreements.

Consider requesting:

• Aggregated traffic patterns to inform property decisions
• General performance indicators to track health of the partnership
• Customer insight sharing from loyalty programs

In exchange, properties can offer:

• Property-wide performance metrics
• Collaborative marketing opportunities
• Priority consideration in property improvements

This mutual exchange strengthens the partnership and improves decision-making for both parties.

Balancing Protection with Flexibility

Exclusivity provisions require careful consideration to protect anchor investments while maintaining leasing flexibility.

Our recommended approach:

• Define protected uses specifically rather than broadly
• Consider time-limited or performance-based exclusivity
• Preserve flexibility for emerging categories and formats

For example, rather than granting broad food exclusivity to a grocer, consider protecting "full-service supermarket operations exceeding 20,000 square feet." This maintains their competitive protection while allowing specialty food, QSR, and smaller format concepts that enhance rather than compete.

Strategic Leasing Sequencing Around Your Anchor

With your anchor secured, a thoughtful leasing sequence helps maximize the value creation opportunity:

Phase 1: Natural Complements

Focus on tenants with clear synergies to the anchor:

• For grocery: services, QSR, daily needs retailers
• For off-price: value-oriented soft goods, beauty, seasonal concepts
• For medical: wellness services, childcare, health-focused dining

These tenants benefit most directly from anchor traffic and typically command strong lease terms due to obvious synergies.

Phase 2: Experience Enhancement

Layer in tenants that deepen the customer experience:

• Differentiated dining options
• Lifestyle and wellness concepts
• Regional and specialty retailers

These uses extend visit duration and frequency, creating a more compelling destination.

Phase 3: Stability Anchors

Complete your mix with service-oriented tenants:

• Professional and medical services
• Education and enrichment
• Financial services

These tenants provide consistent daytime traffic and long-term lease stability, balancing your tenant roster.

Tracking Performance and Optimizing Results

Successful anchor strategies require ongoing monitoring and adjustment. We recommend establishing clear metrics from the start:

Early Indicators

• Traffic pattern changes
• Leasing inquiry activity
• Community engagement metrics

Performance Benchmarks

• Tenant sales trends in anchor-adjacent spaces
• Cross-shopping behavior between anchor and inline tenants
• Operational metrics like parking utilization

Long-term Value Metrics

• NOI growth trajectory
• Comparative lease rates achieved
• Overall property valuation impact

Building Portfolio Intelligence:Properties that systematically track these metrics can identify successful patterns and replicate them across other assets, turning individual successes into portfolio-wide strategies.

Emerging Anchor Models Showing Promise

Based on current market trends and our recent feasibility work, several anchor strategies are demonstrating strong performance:

The Integrated Health and Wellness Model

Properties combining medical services with wellness retail, fitness, and health-focused dining are creating resilient, all-day traffic patterns that support diverse tenant mixes.

The Value-Oriented Ecosystem

Off-price and value retailers paired with complementary discount concepts and experience-based tenants are successfully capturing value-conscious consumers while maintaining strong traffic.

The Specialty and Ethnic Market Approach

Specialized grocers serving specific communities, paired with culturally relevant services and dining, are creating differentiated destinations with loyal customer bases.

Each model requires tailored co-tenancy strategies and lease structures, but properties executing these approaches thoughtfully are seeing meaningful performance improvements.

Moving Forward: From Strategy to Execution

For properties considering new anchor opportunities:Apply systematic evaluation frameworks before entering negotiations. Comprehensive analysis early in the process leads to better outcomes than trying to fix problematic terms later.

For properties with existing anchors:Even established anchor relationships can be optimized. Strategic co-tenancy curation and marketing collaboration can unlock value from current anchors.

For properties facing repositioning:Anchor strategy often determines repositioning success. Starting with the right anchor framework sets the foundation for everything that follows.

How CRE 360 Partners With You

We bring unique advantages to anchor strategy development:

1. Cross-Market Intelligence: Our work with both retailers and landlords provides insights into what drives successful partnerships from both perspectives
2. Data-Driven Validation: Every recommendation is grounded in market analysis and performance data, not assumptions
3. End-to-End Support: From initial feasibility through deal execution, we partner with you throughout the entire process

Ready to explore your anchor strategy opportunities? Schedule a consultation today.

‍